Top 10 Worst Reality show winners according to Comcast.net

Taylor Hicks, 'American Idol'

It was a close call (Ruben! Fantasia!), but Season 5's Taylor Hicks wins the title of the Worst 'Idol,' for his lack of actual talent, poor album sales, the 'Soul Patrol'...really, we can't fit it all here.







Vecepia Towery, 'Survivor: Marquesas'

There are plenty of 'under-the-radar' style players lurking undeservedly in the 'Survivor' history books...and Vecepia is at the top of the list.


Jeffrey Sebelia, 'Project Runway'

Whether he was the victim of bad editing or he was just bad, 'Project Runway's' Jeffrey Sebelia emerged as both the villain and the winner of Season 3.






Ilan Hall, 'Top Chef'

Most fans were spitting mad when Ilan Hall stole the 'Top Chef' title from the more deserving and more likable Sam Talbot in Season 2.



Mike 'Boogie' Malin, 'Big Brother'

Obnoxious 'Big Brother' Season 2 contestant Mike 'Boogie' Malin actually pulled off the win for 'Big Brother: All-Stars' by being the lesser of two evils. But still evil.



'The Apprentice'

Pretty much every winner outside of Season 1's Bill Rancic could be considered the worst, since, well, can anybody name any of the other seven 'Apprentice' winners?




Zach and Flo, 'The Amazing Race'

Zach and Flo won an amazingly agonizing 'Race' around the world in Season 3, mostly because Flo cracked under the pressure and was a grating whiner at every turn. Zach should have gotten to keep the million bucks to himself for having the patience of a saint.



Saleisha Stowers, 'America's Next Top Model'

Perhaps one of Tyra's most controversial picks was Saleisha, who was generally unliked by fans. And in fashion, there's nothing worse than 'plain' and 'boring.





Lucas Rossi, 'Rock Star: Supernova'

Lucas Rossi was the final 'Rock Star' chosen to front the band 'Supernova,' which turned out to be a total dud.









Shayne Lamas, 'The Bachelor'

Matt Grant should have known what he was in for when he learned Shayne was an 'actress' and the daughter of Lorenzo Lamas. But he picked the hottest chick in his 'Bachelor' bunch...and she allegedly cheated on him within one month of the show's finale.




Thats their top 10! I would love to hear everyone elses opinion on their least favorite reality show winner or winners!! I'll start if off with Maggie and Booger from Big Brother, Fantasia from AI, and Brian Heidik (the last part of his last name says it all) from Survivor.
I'm sure I have more I just cant think of them right now..lol! Lets hear it!

I agree with all of those!

My Top 10:
1. Maggie Asburn (Big Brother 6)
2. Ruben Studdard (American Idol 2)
3. Mike Malin (Big Brother 7)
4. Vecepia Towery (Survivor 4)
5. Fantasia Barrino (American Idol 3)
6. Taylor Hicks (American Idol 5)
7. Earl Cole (Survivor 14)
8. Chris Daughtery (Survivor 9)
9. Adrienne Curry (America's Next Top Model 1)
10. BJ & Tyler (The Amazing Race 9)

I don't even watch some of those shows, that being the case they should have a list of worst reality shows ever.


As far as Big Brother is concerned
I agree with Maggie being one of the worst interestingly enough she came from one of my fav seasons. Oh and let's not forget Dick - his name just sums it up for me.

American Idol ... this show really has only produced barely a handful of real talent that people really want to listen to in the mainstream. So my picks are...
Rubben Studdard and Taylor Hicks

Colton!!! I loved BJ and Tyler, the hippies right?? They made me laugh so much and I was so glad when they beat the frat boys. Those bastards cancelled everyones cabs!! LOL

I am glad to see you agree about Fantasia. I could never understand why the AI judges slobbered over her so much. She sounded very nasel and screechy to me. Plus she looked like a chicken when she was singing..LOL. She could have lip synched if she wanted to and those judges would still have wet themselves...made me sick actually. I respectfully disagree about Ruben Studdard though, I really thought he had a great voice.

I know I have some more that I cant stand....probably whoever wins Survivor Gabon...LOL

respectfully disagree against Ruben Studdard?

TOTALLY OVERRATED!!!


And I really liked Fantasia!

Yes, I RESPECTFULLY disagree but since the gloves are off now....I think you have that backwards....Fantasia was WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY overrated by the AI judges and the public. She was horrible.

Oh yeah Ruben was such a velvet teddy bear " longdesc="118" />

LOL...I forgot they called him that. Would that make Fantasia the velvet chicken?? His voice reminded me of Luther Vandross though, and he actually did have talent. Basically he blew it because the fame got to his head. I heard stories of him and his crew, which included his brother, acting cocky and expecting red carpet treatment wherever they went. How much of that is true, I don't know. I did read not too long ago that he lost alot of weight and he needed to..sheesh!

LOL @ him and his crew

what a crew!